ChiroACCESS Clinical Review



Thoracic Outlet Syndrome: Diagnosis

This information is provided to you for use in conjunction with your clinical judgment and the specific needs of the patient.

Lead Author(s): 

Dwain M. Daniel, D.C.

  

How this evidence was rated:

Strength of Recommendation Taxonomy (SORT)



Published on

August 3, 2010

Text Size:     
Thoracic outlet syndrome is the center of a raging controversy in the healthcare field.  Vanti et al stated “Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) has been one of the most debated clinical topics over the last 120 years” (1).  Some experts feel it is over-diagnosed (2) while others think it is under-diagnosed (3).  The fact that 120 TOS surgeries were performed at the Mayo Clinic over a 34 year period while in less than half of that time a single Colorado thoracic surgeon performed 1400 TOS surgeries is indicative of the controversy relating to TOS (4).  Cherington in an editorial states the disputed form of TOS “in which no objective clinical, radiologic or electrodiagnostic abnormalities are documented, is the most commonly diagnosed and surgically treated form of TOS” (5).  This form of TOS represents 85% (1) to 95% (6) of all TOS cases.  Based on a large majority of opinions TOS is almost always a clinical diagnosis without confirming objective evidence.

Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) results from compression of the neurovascular structures as they pass through the thoracic outlet, primarily the interscalene triangle, the costo-clavicular space and the subpectoral tunnel.  Some authors also include the area anterior to the humeral head, passageway for the median nerve roots and the axilla (1).  Thoracic outlet syndrome is usually categorized as follows (7):
  1. Neurogenic TOS:  Represents up to 95% of all TOS cases and has two subcategories.

    a.  True Neurogenic TOS:  Patients present with subjective symptoms which can be confirmed by objective testing.  According to Burke this form is “as rare as rocking-horse manure” (8)


    b.  Disputed Neurogenic TOS:  Patients present with subjective complaints which cannot be objectively confirmed,  The subjective symptoms often include upper extremity heaviness, fatigability, neck, face and shoulder pain and extremity paresthesias. These cases represent up to 99% of neurogenic TOS.


  2. Venous TOS:  These cases are characterized by swelling of the upper extremity, heaviness, pain with activity and paresthesias.  They represent 2 to 3% of TOS cases.

  3. Arterial TOS:  This is the least common form and represents less than 1% of TOS patients.  Pain, paresthesias, cyanosis, fatigability, coldness and color changes are common presentations.  Arterial TOS is often asymptomatic until an embolism occurs. 
The difficulty in diagnosis of TOS by provocative tests is demonstrated in the high number of positive results in asymptomatic populations.  Rayan et al found 91% of normal volunteers had a positive response to at least one of three provocative tests (hyperabduction, Adson’s and costo-clavicular tests) (9).  A 1980 photoplethysmographic study found 60% of a normal population, when tested with provocative maneuvers, had arterial obstruction (10).

The reader should be aware that generally less than 5% of patients with TOS can be identified with provocative testing.  The overwhelming majority must be diagnosed based on history and complaints after ruling out other causes.  Thoracic outlet syndrome is primarily an exclusion diagnosis. It should be noted that carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) often manifests similar symptoms as TOS.  Nord et al found that many of the TOS tests also test positive in patients with CTS.  This results in a high false positive rate for TOS in many patients with CTS (11).  This is troublesome since the first step in the diagnostic process is often to rule out CTS (12;13). 

The typical TOS patient is female, between 20 and 50 years old, has a history of neck trauma and complains of arm pain and paresthesias (14).

AttentionIn order to view the full content of this review, which includes information broken down by topic, you must be a registered user of ChiroACCESS. The primary mission of ChiroACCESS is to disseminate accurate user-friendly information to practicing chiropractors, faculty and students of chiropractic in order to ensure the best possible patient care.

Please click on the following link in order to register at ChiroACCESS and view the full detail of this clinical review.

If you already have an account, you may log in at this time.



References

1. 

Vanti C, Natalini L, Romeo A, Tosarelli D, Pillastrini P. Conservative treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome. A review of the literature. Eura Medicophys 2007 Mar;43(1):55-70.

 [ Medline ID 16955064 ]

2. 

Wilbourn AJ. Thoracic outlet syndrome is overdiagnosed. Muscle Nerve 1999 Jan;22(1):130-6.

 [ Medline ID 2310317 ]

3. 

Roos DB. Thoracic outlet syndrome is underdiagnosed. Muscle Nerve 1999 Jan;22(1):126-9.

 [ Medline ID 9883869 ]

4. 

Naidu S, Kothari M. Thoracic outlet syndrome: does fiction outweigh facts? Curr Opin Orthop 14, 209-214. 2003.



5. 

Cherington M. Thoracic outlet syndrome: Rise of the conservative viewpoint. Am Fam Physician 1991 Jun;43(6):1998.

 [ Medline ID 2042542 ]

6. 

Sanders RJ, Hammond SL, Rao NM. Thoracic outlet syndrome: a review. Neurologist 2008 Nov;14(6):365-73.

 [ Medline ID 19008742 ]

7. 

Nichols AW. Diagnosis and management of thoracic outlet syndrome. Curr Sports Med Rep 2009 Sep;8(5):240-9.

 [ Medline ID 19741351 ]

8. 

Burke D. Symptoms of thoracic outlet syndrome in women with carpal tunnel syndrome. Clin Neurophysiol 2006 Apr;117(4):930-1.

 [ Medline ID 16495146 ]

9. 

Rayan GM, Jensen C. Thoracic outlet syndrome: provocative examination maneuvers in a typical population. J Shoulder Elbow Surg 1995 Mar;4(2):113-7.

 [ Medline ID 7600161 ]

10. 

Gergoudis R, Barnes RW. Thoracic outlet arterial compression: prevalence in normal persons. Angiology 1980 Aug;31(8):538-41.

 [ Medline ID 7436043 ]

11. 

Nord KM, Kapoor P, Fisher J, Thomas G, Sundaram A, Scott K, et al. False positive rate of thoracic outlet syndrome diagnostic maneuvers. Electromyogr Clin Neurophysiol 2008 Mar;48(2):67-74.

 [ Medline ID 18435210 ]

12. 

Abe M, Ichinohe K, Nishida J. Diagnosis, treatment, and complications of thoracic outlet syndrome. J Orthop Sci 1999;4(1):66-9.

 [ Medline ID 9914431 ]

13. 

Lord LW, Jr. Thoracic outlet syndromes. Real or imaginary? N Y State J Med 1981 Sep;81(10):1488-9.

 [ Medline ID 6944615 ]

14. 

Talu GK. Thoracic outlet syndrome. Agri 17[2], 5-9. 2005.



15. 

Seror P. Symptoms of thoracic outlet syndrome in women with carpal tunnel syndrome. Clin Neurophysiol 2005 Oct;116(10):2324-9.

 [ Medline ID 16098808 ]

16. 

Gillard J, Perez-Cousin M, Hachulla E, Remy J, Hurtevent JF, Vinckier L, et al. Diagnosing thoracic outlet syndrome: contribution of provocative tests, ultrasonography, electrophysiology, and helical computed tomography in 48 patients. Joint Bone Spine 2001 Oct;68(5):416-24.

 [ Medline ID 11707008 ]

17. 

Sanders RJ, Hammond SL, Rao NM. Diagnosis of thoracic outlet syndrome. J Vasc Surg 2007 Sep;46(3):601-4.

 [ Medline ID 17826254 ]

18. 

Muizelaar JP, Zwienenberg-Lee M. When it is not cervical radiculopathy: thoracic outlet syndrome--a prospective study on diagnosis and treatment. Clin Neurosurg 2005;52:243-9.

 [ Medline ID 16626077 ]

19. 

Costigan DA, Wilbourn AJ. The elevated arm stress test : specificity in the diagnosis of the thoracic outlet syndrome. Neurology 25[Suppl 1], 74-75. 1985. Ref Type: Journal (Full)



20. 

Warrens AN, Heaton JM. Thoracic outlet compression syndrome: the lack of reliability of its clinical assessment. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 1987 Sep;69(5):203-4.

 [ Medline ID 3674682 ]

21. 

Marx RG, Bombardier C, Wright JG. What do we know about the reliability and validity of physical examination tests used to examine the upper extremity? J Hand Surg Am 1999 Jan;24(1):185-93.

 [ Medline ID 10048536 ]

22. 

Plewa MC, Delinger M. The false-positive rate of thoracic outlet syndrome shoulder maneuvers in healthy subjects. Acad Emerg Med 1998 Apr;5(4):337-42.

 [ Medline ID 9562199 ]

23. 

Woods WW. Thoracic outlet syndrome. West J Med 1978 Jan;128(1):9-12.

 [ Medline ID 625979 ]

24. 

Raskin NH, Howard MW, Ehrenfeld WK. Headache as the leading symptom of the thoracic outlet syndrome. Headache 1985 Jun;25(4):208-10.

 [ Medline ID 4019182 ]

25. 

Baltopoulos P, Tsintzos C, Prionas G, Tsironi M. Exercise-induced scalenus syndrome. Am J Sports Med 2008 Feb;36(2):369-74.

 [ Medline ID 4019182 ]

26. 

Felson B. A Review of 30,000 normal chest roentgenograms. In: Felson B, editor. Chest Roentgenology.Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders; 1973. p. 494.



27. 

Brewin J, Hill M, Ellis H. The prevalence of cervical ribs in a London population. Clin Anat 2009 Apr;22(3):331-6.

 [ Medline ID 19280652 ]

28. 

Demondion X, Herbinet P, Van Sint JS, Boutry N, Chantelot C, Cotten A. Imaging assessment of thoracic outlet syndrome. Radiographics 2006 Nov;26(6):1735-50.

 [ Medline ID 17102047 ]

29. 

Estilaei SK, Byl NN. An evidence-based review of magnetic resonance angiography for diagnosing arterial thoracic outlet syndrome. J Hand Ther 2006 Oct;19(4):410-9.

 [ Medline ID 17056401 ]

30. 

Demondion X, Bacqueville E, Paul C, Duquesnoy B, Hachulla E, Cotten A. Thoracic outlet: assessment with MR imaging in asymptomatic and symptomatic populations. Radiology 2003 May;227(2):461-8.

 [ Medline ID 12637678 ]

31. 

Smedby O, Rostad H, Klaastad O, Lilleas F, Tillung T, Fosse E. Functional imaging of the thoracic outlet syndrome in an open MR scanner. Eur Radiol 2000;10(4):597-600.

 [ Medline ID 10795541 ]

32. 

Sobey AV, Grewal RP, Hutchison KJ, Urschel JD. Investigation of nonspecific neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome. J Cardiovasc Surg (Torino) 1993 Aug;34(4):343-5.

 [ Medline ID 8227118 ]

33. 

Stapleton C, Herrington L, George K. Sonographic evaluation of the subclavian artery during thoracic outlet syndrome shoulder manoeuvres. Man Ther 2009 Feb;14(1):19-27.

 [ Medline ID 17928256 ]

34. 

Urschel JD, Hameed SM, Grewal RP. Neurogenic thoracic outlet syndromes. Postgrad Med J 1994 Nov;70(829):785-9.

 [ Medline ID 7824410 ]

35. 

Parziale JR, Akelman E, Weiss AP, Green A. Thoracic outlet syndrome. Am J Orthop (Belle Mead NJ ) 2000 May;29(5):353-60.

 [ Medline ID 10868435 ]

36. 

Cherington M. A conservative point of view of the thoracic outlet syndrome. Am J Surg 1989 Nov;158(5):394-5.

 [ Medline ID 2817217 ]

37. 

Sheth RN, Belzberg AJ. Diagnosis and treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome. Neurosurg Clin N Am 2001 Apr;12(2):295-309.

 [ Medline ID 11525208 ]